* remove leftover debug line
* terraform: refactor ProviderEvalTree
This PR refactors the ProviderEvalTree by folding the entire tree into
straight-through code in NodeApplyableProvider Execute (formally
EvalTree). The EvalConfigProvider functions were refactored into
NodeApplyableProvider functions (since that was the only place they were
used).
I also removed the unused node_provider_disabled code.
* revert removal of graphNodeCloseProvider EvalTree, replace with Execute
This commit continues the overall EvalNode removal project.
Something to note: the NodeRefreshableDataResourceInstance's Execute()
function is intentionally refactored in the bare minimum,
hardly-a-refactor style, because we have another ongoing project which
aims to remove NodeRefreshable*s. It is not worth the effort at this
time. We may revisit this decision in the future.
When configuring providers, it is normally valid to refer to any value
which is known at apply time. This can include resource instance
attributes, variables, locals, and so on.
The import command has a simpler graph evaluation, which means that
many of these values are unknown. We previously prevented this from
happening by restricting provider configuration references to input
variables (#22862), but this was more restrictive than is necessary.
This commit changes how we verify provider configuration for import.
We no longer inspect the configuration references during graph building,
because this is too early to determine if these values will become known
or not.
Instead, when the provider is configured during evaluation, we
check if the configuration value is wholly known. If not, we fail with a
diagnostic error.
Includes a test case which verifies that providers can now be configured
using locals as well as vars, and an updated test case which verifies
that providers cannot be configured with references to resources.
EvalContext.InitProvider no longer needs the redundant typ String
terraform.contextComponentFactory refactored to take an addrs.Provider
instead of a string.
a large refactor to addrs.AbsProviderConfig, embedding the addrs.Provider instead of a Type string. I've added and updated tests, added some Legacy functions to support older state formats and shims, and added a normalization step when reading v4 (current) state files (not the added tests under states/statefile/roundtrip which work with both current and legacy-style AbsProviderConfig strings).
The remaining 'fixme' and 'todo' comments are mostly going to be addressed in a subsequent PR and involve looking up a given local provider config's FQN. This is fine for now as we are only working with default assumption.
* Introduce "Local" terminology for non-absolute provider config addresses
In a future change AbsProviderConfig and LocalProviderConfig are going to
become two entirely distinct types, rather than Abs embedding Local as
written here. This naming change is in preparation for that subsequent
work, which will also include introducing a new "ProviderConfig" type
that is an interface that AbsProviderConfig and LocalProviderConfig both
implement.
This is intended to be largely just a naming change to get started, so
we can deal with all of the messy renaming. However, this did also require
a slight change in modeling where the Resource.DefaultProviderConfig
method has become Resource.DefaultProvider returning a Provider address
directly, because this method doesn't have enough information to construct
a true and accurate LocalProviderConfig -- it would need to refer to the
configuration to know what this module is calling the provider it has
selected.
In order to leave a trail to follow for subsequent work, all of the
changes here are intended to ensure that remaining work will become
obvious via compile-time errors when all of the following changes happen:
- The concept of "legacy" provider addresses is removed from the addrs
package, including removing addrs.NewLegacyProvider and
addrs.Provider.LegacyString.
- addrs.AbsProviderConfig stops having addrs.LocalProviderConfig embedded
in it and has an addrs.Provider and a string alias directly instead.
- The provider-schema-handling parts of Terraform core are updated to
work with addrs.Provider to identify providers, rather than legacy
strings.
In particular, there are still several codepaths here making legacy
provider address assumptions (in order to limit the scope of this change)
but I've made sure each one is doing something that relies on at least
one of the above changes not having been made yet.
* addrs: ProviderConfig interface
In a (very) few special situations in the main "terraform" package we need
to make runtime decisions about whether a provider config is absolute
or local.
We currently do that by exploiting the fact that AbsProviderConfig has
LocalProviderConfig nested inside of it and so in the local case we can
just ignore the wrapping AbsProviderConfig and use the embedded value.
In a future change we'll be moving away from that embedding and making
these two types distinct in order to represent that mapping between them
requires consulting a lookup table in the configuration, and so here we
introduce a new interface type ProviderConfig that can represent either
AbsProviderConfig or LocalProviderConfig decided dynamically at runtime.
This also includes the Config.ResolveAbsProviderAddr method that will
eventually be responsible for that local-to-absolute translation, so
that callers with access to the configuration can normalize to an
addrs.AbsProviderConfig given a non-nil addrs.ProviderConfig. That's
currently unused because existing callers are still relying on the
simplistic structural transform, but we'll switch them over in a later
commit.
* rename LocalType to LocalName
Co-authored-by: Kristin Laemmert <mildwonkey@users.noreply.github.com>
* huge change to weave new addrs.Provider into addrs.ProviderConfig
* terraform: do not include an empty string in the returned Providers /
Provisioners
- Fixed a minor bug where results included an extra empty string
Previously we were using the experimental HCL 2 repository, but now we'll
shift over to the v2 import path within the main HCL repository as part of
actually releasing HCL 2.0 as stable.
This is a mechanical search/replace to the new import paths. It also
switches to the v2.0.0 release of HCL, which includes some new code that
Terraform didn't previously have but should not change any behavior that
matters for Terraform's purposes.
For the moment the experimental HCL2 repository is still an indirect
dependency via terraform-config-inspect, so it remains in our go.sum and
vendor directories for the moment. Because terraform-config-inspect uses
a much smaller subset of the HCL2 functionality, this does still manage
to prune the vendor directory a little. A subsequent release of
terraform-config-inspect should allow us to completely remove that old
repository in a future commit.
Chaange ResourceProvider to providers.Interface starting from the
context, and fix all type errors.
This only replaced some of method calls directly applicable to the
providers themselves. The resource methods will follow.
Due to how often the state and plan types are referenced throughout
Terraform, there isn't a great way to switch them out gradually. As a
consequence, this huge commit gets us from the old world to a _compilable_
new world, but still has a large number of known test failures due to
key functionality being stubbed out.
The stubs here are for anything that interacts with providers, since we
now need to do the follow-up work to similarly replace the old
terraform.ResourceProvider interface with its replacement in the new
"providers" package. That work, along with work to fix the remaining
failing tests, will follow in subsequent commits.
The aim here was to replace all references to terraform.State and its
downstream types with states.State, terraform.Plan with plans.Plan,
state.State with statemgr.State, and switch to the new implementations of
the state and plan file formats. However, due to the number of times those
types are used, this also ended up affecting numerous other parts of core
such as terraform.Hook, the backend.Backend interface, and most of the CLI
commands.
Just as with 5861dbf3fc49b19587a31816eb06f511ab861bb4 before, I apologize
in advance to the person who inevitably just found this huge commit while
spelunking through the commit history.
Previously we had the evaluate methods accept directly an
addrs.InstanceKey and had our evaluator infer a suitable value for
count.index for it, but that prevents us from setting the index to be
unknown in the validation scenario where we may not be able to predict
the number of instances yet but we still want to be able to check that
the configuration block is type-safe for all possible count values.
To achieve this, we separate the concern of deciding on a value for
count.index from the concern of evaluating it, which then allows for
other implementations of this in future. For the purpose of this commit
there is no change in behavior, with the count.index value being populated
whenever the instance key is a number.
This commit does a little more groundwork for the future implementation
of the for_each feature (which'll support each.key and each.value) but
still doesn't yet implement it, leaving it just stubbed out for the
moment.
Provider input is now longer handled with a graph walk, so the code
related to the input graph and walk are no longer needed.
For now the Input method is retained on the ResourceProvider interface,
but it will never be called. Subsequent work to revamp the provider API
will remove this method.
Now that core has access to the provider configuration schema, our input
logic can be implemented entirely within Context.Input, removing the need
to execute a full graph walk to gather input.
This commit replaces the graph walk call with instead just visiting the
provider configurations (explicit and implied) in the root module, using
the schema to prompt.
The code to manage the input graph walk is not yet removed by this commit,
and will be cleaned up in a subsequent commit once we've made sure there
aren't any other callers/tests depending on parts of it.
To avoid a massively-disruptive change to how EvalNode works, we're now
"smuggling" warnings through the error return value for these, but this
depends on all of the Eval machinery correctly handling this special case
and continuing evaluation when only warnings are returned.
Previous changes missed EvalSequence as a place where execution halts on
error. Now it will accumulate diagnostics itself, aborting if any of
them are error diagnostics, and then wrap its own result up in an error
to be returned by the main Eval function, which already treats non-fatal
errors as a special case, though now produces an explicit log message
about that situation to make it easier to spot in trace logs.
This also includes a more detailed warning message for the warning about
provider input being disabled. While this warning should be removed before
we release anyway, having this additional detail is helpful in debugging
tests where it's being returned.
This was incorrectly comparing a cty.Value to an hcl.Body. Now we decode
the body first so we can compare two of cty.Value.
Also includes a fix to a stale comment in buildProviderConfig that was no
longer accurate.
These are all things that ought to be present in normal use but can end up
being nil in incorrect tests. Test debugging is simpler if these things
return errors gracefully, rather than crashing.
While there's no good reason for this to happen in practice, it can arise
in tests if mocks aren't set up quite right, and so we'll catch it and
report it nicely to make test debugging a little easier.
Due to how deeply the configuration types go into Terraform Core, there
isn't a great way to switch out to HCL2 gradually. As a consequence, this
huge commit gets us from the old state to a _compilable_ new state, but
does not yet attempt to fix any tests and has a number of known missing
parts and bugs. We will continue to iterate on this in forthcoming
commits, heading back towards passing tests and making Terraform
fully-functional again.
The three main goals here are:
- Use the configuration models from the "configs" package instead of the
older models in the "config" package, which is now deprecated and
preserved only to help us write our migration tool.
- Do expression inspection and evaluation using the functionality of the
new "lang" package, instead of the Interpolator type and related
functionality in the main "terraform" package.
- Represent addresses of various objects using types in the addrs package,
rather than hand-constructed strings. This is not critical to support
the above, but was a big help during the implementation of these other
points since it made it much more explicit what kind of address is
expected in each context.
Since our new packages are built to accommodate some future planned
features that are not yet implemented (e.g. the "for_each" argument on
resources, "count"/"for_each" on modules), and since there's still a fair
amount of functionality still using old-style APIs, there is a moderate
amount of shimming here to connect new assumptions with old, hopefully in
a way that makes it easier to find and eliminate these shims later.
I apologize in advance to the person who inevitably just found this huge
commit while spelunking through the commit history.
This turned out to be a big messy commit, since the way providers are
referenced is tightly coupled throughout the code. That starts to unify
how providers are referenced, using the format output node Name method.
Add a new field to the internal resource data types called
ResolvedProvider. This is set by a new setter method SetProvider when a
resource is connected to a provider during graph creation. This allows
us to later lookup the provider instance a resource is connected to,
without requiring it to have the same module path.
The InitProvider context method now takes 2 arguments, one if the
provider type and the second is the full name of the provider. While the
provider type could still be parsed from the full name, this makes it
more explicit and, and changes to the name format won't effect this
code.
While merging the cached Input configs in the correct order prevents
overwriting existing config values, it doesn't prevent an earlier
provider from inserting unwanted values into later provider
configurations.
Diff the key-values returned by Input with the pre-input config, and
store only the "answers" that were added during the Input call.
Always call Input, even if we already have some values, since a
previously cached config may not be complete.
Previously when looking up cached provider input, the Input was taken in
its entirety, and only provider configuration fields that weren't in the
saved input were added. This would cause providers in modules to use the
entire configuration from parent modules, even if they themselves had
entirely different configs.
Note: this is only marginally beter than the old behavior. It may be
slightly more correct, but stil can't account for the user's intent, and
may be adding configured values from one provider into another.
Change the PathCacheKey to just join the path on a non-path character
(|), which makes for easier debugging.
Use the configured providers directly, rather than looking for inherited
provider configuration during graph evaluation.
First remove the provider config cache, and the associated
SetProviderConfig and ParentProviderConfig methods on the eval context.
Every provider must be configured, so there's no need to look for
configuration from other provider instances.
The config.ProviderConfig struct now has a Scope field which stores the
proper path for the interpolation scope. To get this metadata to the
interpolator, we add an EvalInterpolatProvider node which can carry the
ProviderConfig, and an InterpolateProvider context method to carry the
ProviderConfig.Scope into the InterplationScope.
Some of the tests could be adjusted to account for the new inheritance
behavior, and some were simply no longer valid and will be removed.
The remaining tests have questions on how they should work in practice.
This mostly concerns orphaned modules where there is no longer a way to
obtain a provider. In some cases we may require that a minimal provider
config be present to handle the destroy process, but we need further
testing.
All disabled code was commented out in this commit to record any
additional comments. The following commit will be a cleanup pass.
During the input walk we stash the values resulting from user input
(if any) in the eval context for use when later walks need to resolve
the provider config.
However, this repository of input results is only able to represent
literal values, since it does not retain the record of which of the keys
have values that are "computed".
Previously we were blindly stashing all of the results, failing to
consider that some of them might be computed. That resulted in the
UnknownValue placeholder being misinterpreted as a literal value when
the data is used later, which ultimately resulted in it clobbering the
actual expression evaluation result and thus causing the provider to
fail to configure itself.
Now we are careful to only retain in this repository the keys whose values
are known statically during the input phase. This eventually gets merged
with the dynamic evaluation results on subsequent walks, with the dynamic
keys left untouched due to their absence from the stored input map.
This fixes#11264.
Currently Terraform is leaking goroutines and with that memory. I know
strictly speaking this maybe isn’t a real concern for Terraform as it’s
mostly used as a short running command line executable.
But there are a few of us out there that are using Terraform in some
long running processes and then this starts to become a problem.
Next to that it’s of course good programming practise to clean up
resources when they're not needed anymore. So even for the standard
command line use case, this seems an improvement in resource management.
Personally I see no downsides as the primary connection to the plugin
is kept alive (the plugin is not killed) and only unused connections
that will never be used again are closed to free up any related
goroutines and memory.
The provider config was not being properly merged across module
boundaries during the Input walk over the graph, so when a provider was
configured at the top level, resources in modules could improperly
trigger a request for input for a provider attribute that's already
defined.
/cc @sethvargo
Prior to this commit, we'd only persist the result of calling Input if
any input was given (len(result) > 0). The result was that every module
would also repeat asking for input even if there was no input to be
asked for.
This commit makes it so that if no input was received, we still set a
sentinel so that modules don't re-ask.
Kristin Laemmert