Since our new approach here works by installing with a synthetic module
configuration block, we need to treat relative paths as a special case
for two reasons:
- Relative paths in module addresses are relative to the file containing
the call rather than the working directory, but -from-module uses the
working directory (and the call is in a synthetic "file" anyway)
- We need to force Terraform to pass the path through to go-getter rather
than just treating it as a relative reference, since we really do want
a copy of the directory in this case, even if it is local.
To address both of these things, we'll detect a relative path and turn it
into an absolute path before beginning installation. This is a bit hacky,
but this is consistent with the general philosophy of the -from-module
implementation where it does hacky things so that the rest of the
installer code can be spared of dealing with its special cases.
This is covered by a couple of existing tests that run init -from-module,
including TestInit_fromModule_dstInSrc which now passes.
It is common for the same module source package to be referenced multiple
times in the same configuration, either because there are literally
multiple instances of the same module source or because a single package
(or repository) contains multiple modules in sub-directories and many
of them are referenced.
To optimize this, here we introduce a simple caching behavior where the
module installer will detect if it's asked to install multiple times from
the same source and produce the second and subsequent directories by
copying the first, rather than by downloading again over the network.
This optimization is applied once all of the go-getter detection has
completed and sub-directory portions have been trimmed, so it is also
able to normalize differently-specified source addresses that all
ultimately detect to the same resolved address. When installing, we
always extract the entire specified package (or repository) and then
reference the specified sub-directory, so we can safely re-use existing
directories when the base package is the same, even if the sub-directory
is different.
However, as a result we do not yet address the fact that the same package
will be stored multiple times _on disk_, which may still be problematic
when referencing large repositories multiple times in
disk-storage-constrained environments. We could address this in a
subsequent change by investigating the use of symlinks where possible.
Since the Registry installer is implemented just as an extra resolution
step in front of go-getter, this optimization applies to registry
modules too. This does not apply to local relative references, which will
continue to just resolve into the already-prepared directory of their
parent module.
The cache of previously installed paths lives only for the duration of
one call to InstallModules, so we will never re-use directories that
were created by previous runs of "terraform init" and there is no risk
that older versions will pollute the cache when attempting an upgrade
from a source address that doesn't explicitly specify a version.
No additional tests are added here because the existing module installer
tests (when TF_ACC=1) already cover the case of installing multiple
modules from the same source.
This will provide the functionality of "terraform init -from-module=...",
which uses the contents of a given module to populate the working
directory.
This mechanism is intended for installing e.g. examples from Terraform
Registry or elsewhere. It's not fully-general since it can't reasonably
install a module from a subdir that refers up to a parent directory, but
that isn't an issue for all reasonable uses of this option.
Martin Atkins