Previously our error message here was confusing and redundant:
Error starting operation: provider.null: invalid version constraint "not valid": Malformed constraint: not valid
Instead, we'll generate a full HCL2 diagnostic here, which results in
something (subjectively) nicer:
Error: Invalid provider version constraint
The value "@ 1.0.0" given for provider.null is not a valid version
constraint.
At the moment this message is an outlier in that the other validation
errors are all still just plain Go errors, but over time we'll want to
adjust all of these to be full diagnostics so that we can embed source
range information in them to help the user find the offending
configuration.
* Verify discovery works without trailing slash on discovery URL
* Update registry API docs with browse and search endpoints
* Add sample request/responses
* Add comment to test to indicate expecations
* Fix typo
* Remove trailing slash weirdness
A common pattern is to conditionally assign to "count"
in a resource in order to decide dynamically whether it
should be created. In that situation it's necessary to
refer to attributes of the resource using the splat
syntax, but historically we didn't show errors in output
expressions and so people "got away with" incorrect usage
in that context.
The intent of this warning is to catch
potentially-problematic usage of attributes on such
resources even if the count happens to be currently
set dynamically to 1, which would not generate the
error. Then the user can quickly locate and fix the
incorrect usage regardless of the current value.
Validation is the best time to return detailed diagnostics
to the user since we're much more likely to have source
location information, etc than we are in later operations.
This change doesn't actually add any detail to the messages
yet, but it changes the interface so that we can gradually
introduce more detailed diagnostics over time.
While here there are some minor adjustments to some of the
messages to improve their consistency with terminology we
use elsewhere.
The level of abstraction that needs the "svchost" is the Module, not the
FriendlyHost. Us the new method in the module package for registry
interaction.
The "not found" error should use the raw string directly from the config
source, but the existing method was adding the default registry if there
was no host indicated.
Use the ResourceState.Provider field to store the full name of the
provider used during apply. This field is only used when a resource is
removed from the config, and will allow that resource to be removed by
the exact same provider with which it was created.
Modify the locations which might accept the alue of the
ResourceState.Provider field to detect that the name is resolved.
Now that resources can be connected to providers with different paths in
the core graph, handling the inheritance in config makes less sense.
Removing this to make room for core to walk the Tree and connect
resources directly to the proper provider instance.
Change "Downloading" to 'Initializing" to match the provider loading
dialog.
List each module being loaded.
If a regisry module is being downloaded, list the registry host, and the
version discovered.
Show the source string from the config that is being fetched, rather
than the go-getter url. The full source can be found in the logs for
debugging.
Add much more extensive logging
Now that providers in the graph can adopt resources without an explicit
provider, there's no need to add the implicit configs to the module.Tree
when loading.
If registry API discovery fails for a particular host then it's better to
generate an explicit error message for that early -- so we can tell the
user exactly what happened -- rather than assuming a default path and
then failing downstream when we get a 404 from that request.
It's not always easy or convenient for a web application to determine its
own absolute URL to return, so here we pragmatically allow the download
source string from a registry to be a path relative to the download
endpoint.
Since X-Terraform-Get is a go-getter string, not all valid values are
valid URLs and so we sniff for certain relative-path-looking prefixes
in order to decide whether to apply the relative lookup transform.
Add GetModule for the cli to initialize from a regisry module source.
Storage.GetModule fetches a module using the same detection and
discovery as used by the normal module loading. The final copy is still
done by module.GetCopy to remove vcs files.
Provide a way to pass in credentials to be used by the module.Storage
when contacting registries.
Remove the mockTLSServer and use a static discovery map pointing to the
http url for tests.
Update the command package to use the new module storage. Move the old
command output strings into the module storage itself. This could be
moved back later either by using ui callbacks, or designing a module
storage interface once we know what the final requirements will look
like.
Exporting ModuleStorage allows us to explicitly pass in the storgae
location rather than extracting it out of the getter.Storage interface,
set a UI for communiating actions back to the user, and accepting a
services Disco for discovery.
If a provider configuration is inherited from another module, any
interpolations in that config won't have variables declared locally. Let
the config only be validated in it's original location.
Registry modules can't be handled directly by the getter.Storage
implementation, which doesn't know how to handle versions. First see if
we have a matching module stored that satisfies our constraints. If
not, and we're getting or updating, we can look it up in the registry.
This essentially takes the place of a "registry detector" for go-getter,
but required the intermediate step of resolving the version dependency.
This also starts breaking up the huge Tree.Load method into more
manageable parts. It was sorely needed, as indicated by the difficulty
encountered in this refactor. There's still a lot that can be done to
improve this, but at least there are now a few easier to read methods
when we come back to it.
The detection of registry modules will have to happen in mutliple
phases. The go-getter interface requires that the detector return the
final URL, while we won't know that until we verify which version we
need. This leaves the regisry sources broken, to be re-integrated in a
following commit.
wire up HTTP so we can test the mock discovery service
test lookupModuleVersions
Add a versions endpoint to the mock registry, and use that to verify the
lookupModuleVersions behavior.
lookupModuleVersions takes a Disco as the argument so a custom Transport
can be injected, and uses that transport for its own client if it set.
test looking up modules with default registry
Add registry.terrform.io to the hostname that the mock registry resolves
to localhost.
ACC test looking up module versions
Lookup a basic module for the available version in the default registry.
This test highlights how changing an intermediate source path prevents
reloading of submodules. While this is somewhat of an edge case now, it
becomes quite common in the cacse where module versions are updated.
Adds basic detector for registry module source strings. While this isn't
a thorough validation, this will eliminate anything that is definitely
not a registry module, and split out our host and module id strings.
lookupModuleVersions interrogates the registry for the available
versions of a particular module and the tree of dependencies.
Submodules were located by using their module path as the storage key.
Now that modules may have versions, a submodule needs to know how to
locate the corect source depending on the versions of its ancestors in
the tree.
Add a version field to each Tree, and a pointer back to the parent Tree
to step back through the ancestors. The new versionedPathKey method uses
this information to build a unique key for each module, dependent on the
ancestor versions.
Not only do stored modules need to know their version if it exists, but
any relative source needs to know all the ancestor versions in order to
resolve correctly.
Masayuki Morita