Previously we were making an invalid assumption in evaluating module call
references (like module.foo) that the module must exist, which is
incorrect for that particular case because it's a reference to a child
module, not to an object within the current module.
However, now that we have the mechanism for static validation of
references, we'll deal with this one there so it can be caught sooner.
That then makes the original assumption valid, though for a different
reason.
This is verified by two new context tests for validation:
- TestContext2Validate_invalidModuleRef
- TestContext2Validate_invalidModuleOutputRef
In the initial move to HCL2 we started relying only on full expression
evaluation to catch attribute errors, but that's not sufficient for
resource attributes in practice because during validation we can't know
yet whether a resource reference evaluates to a single object or to a
list of objects (if count is set).
To address this, here we reinstate some static validation of resource
references by analyzing directly the reference objects, disregarding any
instance index if present, and produce errors if the remaining subsequent
traversal steps do not correspond to items within the resource type
schema.
This also allows us to produce some more specialized error messages for
certain situations. In particular, we can recognize a reference like
aws_instance.foo.count, which in 0.11 and prior was a weird special case
for determining the count value of a resource block, and offer a helpful
error showing the new length(aws_instance.foo) usage pattern.
This eventually delegates to the static traversal validation logic that
was added to the configschema package in a previous commit, which also
includes some specialized error messages that distinguish between
attributes and block types in the schema so that the errors relate more
directly to constructs the user can see in the configuration.
In future we could potentially move more of the checks from the dynamic
schema construction step to the static validation step, but resources
are the reference type that most needs this immediately due to the
ambiguity caused by the instance indexing syntax. We can safely refactor
other reference types to be statically validated in later releases.
This is verified by two pre-existing context validate tests which we
temporarily disabled during earlier work (now re-enabled) and also by a
new validate test aimed specifically at the special case for the "count"
attribute.
The test suite was not updated to deal with the new assumptions of the
HCL2-based expression evaluator, which requires configuration to exist
as well as state. Therefore we add a simple configuration fixture to have
it validate expressions against.
This also includes updates to expect the different error messages that the
new evaluator produces.
There are still some errors left, because our expression evaluator now
does more validation than before and so we'll need to (in a subsequent
commit) actually use a fixture configuration for these tests so that the
validations will allow the expressions to be validated.
Martin Atkins